Project Natal versus PS3 new motion sensor ?

What do u guyz have to say abt this ?

i need to see a live demo of Project Natal before i make up my mind, and not just the lady flailing her arms at balls or the two people + pillows making an elephant. nobody wants to do that.

I dunno about Natal. I mean, painting - you can only go so far with that really. Stencilling (the elephant), well you'd have to have quite a good imagination for that to last, Milo seems quite impossible at the moment and I think I need to try it for myself, and I don't know what other type of things you could do that involve actions/triggers (shooters/action buttons etc.) So I dunno really. Not convinced on either at the moment.

I dunno about Natal. I mean, painting - you can only go so far with that really. Stencilling (the elephant), well you'd have to have quite a good imagination for that to last, Milo seems quite impossible at the moment and I think I need to try it for myself, and I don't know what other type of things you could do that involve actions/triggers (shooters/action buttons etc.) So I dunno really. Not convinced on either at the moment.

Milo is crap. If it was good I would give it respect but it is crap. I read an article where this guy was saying he tried it out and it didn't understand what he was saying most of the time.

Project Natal is a really hood technology, but the way they presented it was crap.


Me as a gamer, i dont want to draw and become and 'elephant', i dont want to choose how to dress for the party nor be a monster and look like a retard.


Yet Sony's Motion is still a prototype and they have over a year to work on it, since the guy who created it (eyetoy) is a genious, he will take a good advantage of it, like he said he wants more of the hardcore croud, if they can get this to work well on hack and slash games and RPG games, than it wins, if not we cant tell for now since non of them are out yet.


But with the Milo thing, great idea, if you have no life and you dont have anyone to talk to, i mean if you guys really want to ask Milo if he did his homework...go ahead..

Project Natal looks pretty exciting right now ! Not sure how will it work though ! Lionhead studios showed that demo ! The demo was really good ! But the question is that was it predefined or prescripted ?


But check this out ! Celebrities are trying out Project Natal :

It looks sweet, im so going to get it

me too ! Looks promising but donno how it will workout though.

I dont know the place they had it was a space with nothing inside, and im pretty sure who ever buys it will play ricochet only 5 times and then never play it again just like wii sports.

Sony's motion control system looks as if it'll work better. The demo they showed was great, and Project Natal doesn't seem as if it'll work to well. Especially Milo. Can you say Judgement Day?

Well...also if they can fix the Natal...then it might be better...but the PlayStation motion control looked for promising.

i think everybody is being to harsh on Natal, it hink it looks cool. who wouldn't want to be able to virtually pick out what they want to wear that day??? cause i know that's like a dream come true to me.

ilovekeith wrote:

i think everybody is being to harsh on Natal, it hink it looks cool. who wouldn't want to be able to virtually pick out what they want to wear that day??? cause i know that's like a dream come true to me.

I don't lol. I bet no one remembers that but you lol.

I see the words "Invalid Parameter"

atyre5 wrote:

I see the words "Invalid Parameter"

where lol!

They're both going to suck. I do not want Sony and MS venturing into that market at all.

I don't know. I am kind of curious on both of them.

It's one of those things where you have to try it to decide I think.

They could both be amazing, and they could both be huge letdowns. Only time will tell.

i still like controllers!

IDK...I think it would be cool.

if out of the two, i will go for Natal!

Rashid Sayed wrote:

if out of the two, i will go for Natal!

If natal can work like that say it will work...it will be awesome. But if you watch closely, everything they did on the stage demo of natal, was about a half second delay. It was annoying.

Keith Deitz wrote:

Rashid Sayed wrote:

if out of the two, i will go for Natal!

If natal can work like that say it will work...it will be awesome. But if you watch closely, everything they did on the stage demo of natal, was about a half second delay. It was annoying.

I noticed that. That didn't happen during the PS3 demo. And the PS3 demo actually showed something that people care about. RTS, FPS, and RPG combat. Natal just showed 3D Bricks.